Feedback
Thank you for your purchase. If you like your product, please email me.I very much appreciate your feedback. Good listening!
PolyTable Signature
Hi George:Here is my honest review. The Poly Signature has been a real eye-opener for me. As I said, I had no idea vinyl could sound this good. And I know the main reason it sounds so good is your knowledge that is designed into this thing. Feel free to post my review below.
I am new to vinyl. For a short period, I previously had a tricked-out Garrard 401 with an upgraded bearing and the Long Dog PS. The Garrard sounded great, but there was an inherent level of noise/rumble that bothered me and I knew I could not live with it long-term. After doing some research online, I gave George Merril a call. After the conversation, I immediately knew that the course of action for me was to sell the Garrard and get a Polytable Signature.Working with George was great. He is extremely knowledgeable about all things related to turntable design. After speaking to him over the phone, reading about his philosophy on turntable design and vibration management, and corresponding by email, I quickly realized that the vast majority of tables out there are designed to either (or both) (a) appeal to the eye, and/or (b) built to a given price point. Very few tables out there really pay much attention to vibration control, although their marketing literature often makes unfounded claims that they do. As I learned from George, tables made from mdf, wood, metal, etc., despite all the marketing claims, do not properly dampen vibrations.
I’ve never set up a tonearm before. But with the Polytable Signature, it is relatively easy to do.
The sound is staggeringly good, much better than the Garrard, and leaps and bounds beyond streaming Qobuz. Records sound so vivid and alive. Music has a real presence, dimensionality, and solidity in my room. Stereo separation is incredible, way better than streaming. And just as much slam, if not more, than the Garrard. Operation is dead silent.
I have always been content with streaming my music. I liked the convenience and figured analog was marginally better. The Polytable Signature has completely changed my mindset. I had no idea records could sound this good. Thanks, George for designing and making this amazing product. Jim
I’ve never set up a tonearm before. But with the Polytable Signature, it is relatively easy to do.
The sound is staggeringly good, much better than the Garrard, and leaps and bounds beyond streaming Qobuz. Records sound so vivid and alive. Music has a real presence, dimensionality, and solidity in my room. Stereo separation is incredible, way better than streaming. And just as much slam, if not more, than the Garrard. Operation is dead silent.
I have always been content with streaming my music. I liked the convenience and figured analog was marginally better. The Polytable Signature has completely changed my mindset. I had no idea records could sound this good. Thanks, George for designing and making this amazing product. Jim
PolyTable Upgrade
You hover above the earth and will never need to re-sole your shoes George.
The package arrived and I retrofitted the Polytable with the DMD as per your instructions. Good lord. Wasn’t prepared for the sorts and amounts of improvements.
Better all-round focus, an easing of whatever variations would sometimes intrude when playing solo piano or other sustained instruments, particularly rewarding In jazz combos and with vocals.
Didn’t realize how trashy my so-called 60-Hz power actually was, or how off the 33 or 45 RPM speeds must have been now and then without the DMD.
Many, many thanks.
-Lewis
The package arrived and I retrofitted the Polytable with the DMD as per your instructions. Good lord. Wasn’t prepared for the sorts and amounts of improvements.
Better all-round focus, an easing of whatever variations would sometimes intrude when playing solo piano or other sustained instruments, particularly rewarding In jazz combos and with vocals.
Didn’t realize how trashy my so-called 60-Hz power actually was, or how off the 33 or 45 RPM speeds must have been now and then without the DMD.
Many, many thanks.
-Lewis
PolyTable Turntable Feedback from Switzerland
Good day GeorgeThe Polytable has some more hours in it now and it became even better. I must admit that I couldn’t believe that ‘only’ the turntable can bring such a drastic improvement in any way (details, better in high/medium/low, musicality, more room, black background…) over the Pro-Ject Classic Evo which is not that cheap, selling for around USD 1’900.-. It shouldn’t sound so terrible compared to the PolyTable 😊 !!!!No regrets to have taken the ring right from the beginning as it’s improving the details of the low without any harm on the high tones, this not only on the outer grooves but on the whole record.Somehow, the Sorbothane feet have stopped moving around and I’m happy to keep them as they are because it’s pretty obvious that they are improving the sound even on the rack with magnetic decoupling feet from Levitations. I am reassured to hear that you can stop the engine by hand, the handling (especially with the ring) is getting easier and quicker.
Wishing you a great daySascha
PolyTable Turntable
A study in contrasts:100% function, 0% form.100% Hume, 0% Plato.100% empericism, 0% rationalism.100% substance, 0% fluff.
The PolyTable is a standing triumph of function over form, of substance over fluff. It looks striking, cool even (though it could be argued with some merit that "cool" lies in the eyes of the beholder), but there's more to the story.
Terms like "bouncy" and "punchy" and "dead" often pop up in reviews of turntables. These mean nothing if not tied to a scientifically verifiable correlation that can be measured, observed, repeated. The PolyTable's creator and designer, George Merrill, applied an almost Volvoesque pathology to one singular requirement: pure and unvitiated sound reproduction. Watch his videos and you will see oscilloscopes and hear references to stethoscopes -- scientific instruments in the service of The Goal. The 'table, according to Merrill, "has no personality". Its marriage to the Sorane TA-1L 12.7" tonearm, noted for its probity, its neutrality, for eschewing the "[suggestion of] a sound" and the addition of "special sounds" (source: https://mockingbirddistribution.com/sorane/ta1l/) layered above the signal picked up by the cartridge, therefore comes as no surpise.
A beautiful contraption it is not, unless beauty be defined as critical path engineering in the purest sense. To a certain segment of the population, that is the very epitome of beauty: no-nonsense function over nicety and form. Clearly, the Louis Vuitton set is not its target market -- other manufacturerers cater to that segment in the same price range (I'm looking at you, Vertere). Its half-Goldberg, half-Escher form serves the function of truthful sound reproduction through effective energy management (minimization of vibrations both external and internal/tracing-related), the culmination of evolution of Merrill's long and storied career that began with AR mods in the 1970s, through to the Heirloom and various other products to the PolyTable.
While the PolyTable might appear as a toweing Rube Goldberg contraption, even a cursory examination will show that each facet of the design serves a specific purpose. The frontal protrusion holds the built-in spirit level for easy viewing. The multiple platters sandwiched with RCC mats serve to further dampen vibrations.
Clearly there is a link in design philosophy to Rega, with prevalence given to material science over sheer mass, though the PolyTable weighing in at over 30 lbs. is certainly no lightweight.
In contrast to Thorens and the TD-1600/TD-1601 offerings, there is a clean break with tradition, in the finest tradition of the scientific method, allowing the evidence to dictate the conclusion from a new starting point.
In contrast to Vertere's affordable and quite avant-garde offerings, the DG-1/DG-1S, with their almost sirenline visual appeal -- the polish, the angles -- the PolyTable offers none of that, as its angles and protrusions each serve a specific purpose.
It isn't that any one of these 'tables is "better" -- each is a marvel in its own right and all would make their prospective owners quite proud. It's just that the PolyTable is the table of choice for the engineer, the one who prizes science and physical reality above emotional visual appeal, the one who sees more beauty in a well-run industrial operation than in an avante garde museum of modern art. The 'table is simply a means to an end, not the end itself. That end is the music in as close to its original recorded form as possible for a reasonable price.
The end result: The PolyTable delivers a faithful and astonishingly realistic rendering of the music in the groove that leaves the listener wanting more, itself dead silent, inserting none of its own opinion but transcribing only what it traces.
As George says, "When the lights dim to listen, the music is also in the dark."
Greg HedgerPolyTable Signature ownerMay 2023
The PolyTable is a standing triumph of function over form, of substance over fluff. It looks striking, cool even (though it could be argued with some merit that "cool" lies in the eyes of the beholder), but there's more to the story.
Terms like "bouncy" and "punchy" and "dead" often pop up in reviews of turntables. These mean nothing if not tied to a scientifically verifiable correlation that can be measured, observed, repeated. The PolyTable's creator and designer, George Merrill, applied an almost Volvoesque pathology to one singular requirement: pure and unvitiated sound reproduction. Watch his videos and you will see oscilloscopes and hear references to stethoscopes -- scientific instruments in the service of The Goal. The 'table, according to Merrill, "has no personality". Its marriage to the Sorane TA-1L 12.7" tonearm, noted for its probity, its neutrality, for eschewing the "[suggestion of] a sound" and the addition of "special sounds" (source: https://mockingbirddistribution.com/sorane/ta1l/) layered above the signal picked up by the cartridge, therefore comes as no surpise.
A beautiful contraption it is not, unless beauty be defined as critical path engineering in the purest sense. To a certain segment of the population, that is the very epitome of beauty: no-nonsense function over nicety and form. Clearly, the Louis Vuitton set is not its target market -- other manufacturerers cater to that segment in the same price range (I'm looking at you, Vertere). Its half-Goldberg, half-Escher form serves the function of truthful sound reproduction through effective energy management (minimization of vibrations both external and internal/tracing-related), the culmination of evolution of Merrill's long and storied career that began with AR mods in the 1970s, through to the Heirloom and various other products to the PolyTable.
While the PolyTable might appear as a toweing Rube Goldberg contraption, even a cursory examination will show that each facet of the design serves a specific purpose. The frontal protrusion holds the built-in spirit level for easy viewing. The multiple platters sandwiched with RCC mats serve to further dampen vibrations.
Clearly there is a link in design philosophy to Rega, with prevalence given to material science over sheer mass, though the PolyTable weighing in at over 30 lbs. is certainly no lightweight.
In contrast to Thorens and the TD-1600/TD-1601 offerings, there is a clean break with tradition, in the finest tradition of the scientific method, allowing the evidence to dictate the conclusion from a new starting point.
In contrast to Vertere's affordable and quite avant-garde offerings, the DG-1/DG-1S, with their almost sirenline visual appeal -- the polish, the angles -- the PolyTable offers none of that, as its angles and protrusions each serve a specific purpose.
It isn't that any one of these 'tables is "better" -- each is a marvel in its own right and all would make their prospective owners quite proud. It's just that the PolyTable is the table of choice for the engineer, the one who prizes science and physical reality above emotional visual appeal, the one who sees more beauty in a well-run industrial operation than in an avante garde museum of modern art. The 'table is simply a means to an end, not the end itself. That end is the music in as close to its original recorded form as possible for a reasonable price.
The end result: The PolyTable delivers a faithful and astonishingly realistic rendering of the music in the groove that leaves the listener wanting more, itself dead silent, inserting none of its own opinion but transcribing only what it traces.
As George says, "When the lights dim to listen, the music is also in the dark."
Greg HedgerPolyTable Signature ownerMay 2023
George, PolyTable Turntable
Happy New Year. My Poly table is finally up and running. A friend who is quite adept at turntable and cartridge set up has been busy, hence the delay.
The Poly/Sorane is one very impressive combo. It’s an improvement in every manner over my other table/arm, particularly with respect to noise. The Poly/Sorane has a great sense of space with solid, well defined images. I assume that is due, in part, to its amazing quietness. My existing Soundsmith Zephyr cartridge is a great match for the Sorane arm. Detail abounds without be analytical. In short, this is a wonderfully musical system.
A couple friends stopped by for a listening session and were quite impressed. Frank Sinatra’s “All or Nothing at All” in mono stole the show. This LP has a large soundstage that, with the right setup, easily fills the space between the speakers. With Poly/Sorane his voice was almost three dimensional possessing a rock solid, stable image. My friends both thought that was some of the best mono Sinatra they’d ever heard.
Bottom line, my vinyl has never sounded better.
Jim M
Happy New Year. My Poly table is finally up and running. A friend who is quite adept at turntable and cartridge set up has been busy, hence the delay.
The Poly/Sorane is one very impressive combo. It’s an improvement in every manner over my other table/arm, particularly with respect to noise. The Poly/Sorane has a great sense of space with solid, well defined images. I assume that is due, in part, to its amazing quietness. My existing Soundsmith Zephyr cartridge is a great match for the Sorane arm. Detail abounds without be analytical. In short, this is a wonderfully musical system.
A couple friends stopped by for a listening session and were quite impressed. Frank Sinatra’s “All or Nothing at All” in mono stole the show. This LP has a large soundstage that, with the right setup, easily fills the space between the speakers. With Poly/Sorane his voice was almost three dimensional possessing a rock solid, stable image. My friends both thought that was some of the best mono Sinatra they’d ever heard.
Bottom line, my vinyl has never sounded better.
Jim M
Good morning George, PolyTable Turntable
The table continues to break in, but I’m guessing the motor andbearing are done. Mostly, the break-in has to do with recalibrating myexpectations about what’s possible with an all analogue musicreproduction system. The level of detail retrieval, sustain (more onthat later), and the seemingly explosive dynamic presentation this tableand cartridge provides is simply astounding. And based on thetonearm/turntable combo, I’m guessing it would support ANY cartridgeregardless of cost(?). I’m still mulling over the MuTech cart…
My wife was part of an all girls choir at the then all girls School ofNotre Dame in Mankato, MN. The choir director—a nun, ofcourse—trained these girls into a very fine ensemble and ultimatelyproduced a couple of all analogue recordings produced by the DeltaRecords label during the 70’s. The girls were selling thesedoor-to-door and to relatives to pay for the effort as well as to raisemoney for the lil’ monastic community. When we married in the late90’s, I asked a high-end dealer I frequented (Corner Audio inPortland, OR) if I could make a DAT recording of her LP to create a CDwhich I presented to her as a Christmas gift. So, with album and ProAudio DAT in tow, we connected it up to the big QuickSilver preamp (thebig, full faced, and full function one of the time) which was supportinga very fine table and cart that totaled somewhere in the $20K(+/-)range.I made the DAT recording and sent it to a local Pro Audio shop totransfer it to CD. The recording was a hit with my darling wife andthat’s what we listen to every Christmas. Everyone loves it.
Yesterday, the ZOTL40 Reference amp arrived back from Mark Scheider atLinear Tube Audio. (Yeah!) My testing identified that all the NOS tubeswere Ok and Mark confirmed that it was a board level component, which hesaid was, “Very unusual.” After letting things settle in for a bit Istarted listening. All I can say is, WOW! Every album I place on theplatter is a revelation, and that includes my wife’s original albumfrom the 70s. There is absolutely no comparison playing the ripped CDvia the fine Yggdrasil and the PolyTable Signature and HanaML. Mywife’s eye’s (and ears) were transfixed to the“illuminated”—her own words—image coming from the speakers. Shedescribed it as being transported back to the church setting where therecording took place.
And now back to the “sustain” idea in my first paragraph. I’vebeen to the campus at Mankato, MN where my wife attended High School andthe church where the recording was made. The natural reverb in thebuilding is fairly lengthy. In the CD is falls off of a cliff; with thePolySignature it seems to go on, and on, and on, naturally. Remarkable.
I listened to several other records and I just walk away wagging my headat what I’ve been missing.
Thanks again George!
—mark
P.S. The record weight makes a difference. The difference is subtle, butquite perceptible as more focus and solidity. Who knew!?
The table continues to break in, but I’m guessing the motor andbearing are done. Mostly, the break-in has to do with recalibrating myexpectations about what’s possible with an all analogue musicreproduction system. The level of detail retrieval, sustain (more onthat later), and the seemingly explosive dynamic presentation this tableand cartridge provides is simply astounding. And based on thetonearm/turntable combo, I’m guessing it would support ANY cartridgeregardless of cost(?). I’m still mulling over the MuTech cart…
My wife was part of an all girls choir at the then all girls School ofNotre Dame in Mankato, MN. The choir director—a nun, ofcourse—trained these girls into a very fine ensemble and ultimatelyproduced a couple of all analogue recordings produced by the DeltaRecords label during the 70’s. The girls were selling thesedoor-to-door and to relatives to pay for the effort as well as to raisemoney for the lil’ monastic community. When we married in the late90’s, I asked a high-end dealer I frequented (Corner Audio inPortland, OR) if I could make a DAT recording of her LP to create a CDwhich I presented to her as a Christmas gift. So, with album and ProAudio DAT in tow, we connected it up to the big QuickSilver preamp (thebig, full faced, and full function one of the time) which was supportinga very fine table and cart that totaled somewhere in the $20K(+/-)range.I made the DAT recording and sent it to a local Pro Audio shop totransfer it to CD. The recording was a hit with my darling wife andthat’s what we listen to every Christmas. Everyone loves it.
Yesterday, the ZOTL40 Reference amp arrived back from Mark Scheider atLinear Tube Audio. (Yeah!) My testing identified that all the NOS tubeswere Ok and Mark confirmed that it was a board level component, which hesaid was, “Very unusual.” After letting things settle in for a bit Istarted listening. All I can say is, WOW! Every album I place on theplatter is a revelation, and that includes my wife’s original albumfrom the 70s. There is absolutely no comparison playing the ripped CDvia the fine Yggdrasil and the PolyTable Signature and HanaML. Mywife’s eye’s (and ears) were transfixed to the“illuminated”—her own words—image coming from the speakers. Shedescribed it as being transported back to the church setting where therecording took place.
And now back to the “sustain” idea in my first paragraph. I’vebeen to the campus at Mankato, MN where my wife attended High School andthe church where the recording was made. The natural reverb in thebuilding is fairly lengthy. In the CD is falls off of a cliff; with thePolySignature it seems to go on, and on, and on, naturally. Remarkable.
I listened to several other records and I just walk away wagging my headat what I’ve been missing.
Thanks again George!
—mark
P.S. The record weight makes a difference. The difference is subtle, butquite perceptible as more focus and solidity. Who knew!?
George, AR ModificationsI attempted tonight to post on Vinyl Engine the DMD stuff I mentioned today. Here are links to the two different threads. One for the new tables and one for Controlling the Motor. Please feel free to use any of this in any manner you think beneficial. I don’t have any pride in authorship. I only want to spread the word.New Built Tables- Vinyl EngineControl and the AR Motor- Vinyl EngineFrom a business stand point, I know you made substantial investment to design the DMD, but the fact that I don’t see it discussed anywhere tells me the marketing needs help. And you can read what I’m writing, this DMD needs to get a lot more visibility…. It’s just too good at what it does. And look at all the Linn stuff, which I don’t think actually solves the problem… just generates a lot of electronics to fail and then drive repairs or replacements.And maybe with more orders the pricing could come down and drive more orders. I don’t have a good idea of how many AR tables are out there as market source but I think it’s significant. And also, consider international… I know a PITA to deal with but a 50 Hz version will likely drive orders too. Seems to me the only issue is a different wall wort to bring the proper DC voltage to the DMD.One Very Happy Customer,
TJ
TJ
LP 33 1/3 Examples: PolyTable Turntable
Hank Mobley - Workout -
voices and sounds coming out the musicians I've never heard before. Wide soundstage and dynamic range.
Iron Butterfly - Ball -
Bass from Lee Dorman's Bass, Ron Bushy's voice placement was just right on and various guitar fuss, drum set made me feel I was right in there.
Mason Williams - Phonograph Record -
Everything was more expansive and separation was at a maximum. Classical Gas...well the best sound performance I've ever experienced.
Golden Earing -
Moontan A real gem of an album came over like the musicians were live and right there. Punch. Just like the Portland State University live concert of 1985. (without the crowd)I know it's early on.... but your table is impressing the hell out of me.Tears of Joy.Can it get any better?- Jon
Name: Mike Pinsky REPLICA TURNTABLE
My ES-R1 is set up with a Jelco 750 arm and Audio Technica AT7V MM cartridge (good resonance match to the arm), thru an Audio Sensibility Impact phono cable to a Bottlehead Seduction phono pre and a Bottlehead Stereomour 2A3 DHT SET amp.
Speakers are Blumenstein Orcas, assisted by a REL T2 sub. Listening to an ECM disc, Keith Jarret\'s \'Changes\', Jack Dejohnette\'s drum kit had all the snap, drive and tone of the real thing. I spent many an evening sitting 4 feet away from Levon Helm\'s drum kit on the radiator at the Barn, and this is the real deal. You can hear and feel the twang and wood of Gary Peacock\'s bass. No shortage of bass and bass tone here, and there\'s attack aplenty from the bottom on up. This thing swings. Fine psychoacoustics, too.The imaging is precise and soundstage wide and deep. Thank you, George. You did it
Name: AudiogoN RCC Mat
THE killer mat, very solid sound with great detail and less surface noise. Smoked my Herbies and Music Hall mats which are quite decent themselves. Mr. Merill strikes again.
Good evening, George, from out here in western Wyoming. To refresh your memory, I have purchased (to date) one hydraulic cleaning apparatus (with the two solutions), one RCC turntable mat, one polyweight turntable weight, and four durometer decoupling feet. The combination of all these items has measurably improved the sonics coming off of and out of my LP's from my turntable. I couldn't be happier with these results. Having hundreds of lp's, I suspect there will be several super solution and LP elixir orders in the future.
Again, thank you, for your good products.
- Tom Peters
George HCA LP CleanerI wanted to reach out to you about the subject products. As you know, I've purchased several AR ES-1 turntable upgrades from you with great success. I happened to be listening last night to an album I've not heard in a long time; 'Crime of the Century' by 'Supertramp'. I specifically wanted to hear a song called 'Rudy'...a song that fit's today's society quite nicely.In any case, I did the prerequisite brushing, stylus cleaning, etc. and started listening. Oh My! BIG POP! Crackle! an occasional Snap! Wow...this is not an old album, I bought it only a few years ago to replace my original, I've seldom played it. None-the-less, it was noisy. I played this song three or four times before I finally said STOP! There's dirt in this groove, it can't be a scratch. So I pulled out my trusty MkII Record Cleaner plus accessories. I simply wanted to clean the album to rid it of what I figured was dirt. I actually cleaned it twice; that particular POP was that bad and I wanted it gone! I've always thought highly of your record cleaning system, but now...As is typical when I wash an album, I treated it with Groove Lube after it was dry. After a full stylus cleaning, I put it on the table and played it. GOOD! The pops were gone. Things sounded great...I was happy. But then a relatively intense musical passage hit...WOW! That SOUNDED wonderful. I did NOT expect that. When I cleaned this album and treated it with Groove Lube, I expected nothing more than the elimination of the Rice Krispie Brothers...I was not listening for and did not expect THAT kind of difference in sonic quality. But there it was...improved base, less harshness, it was amazing! I suppose the reason it surprised me was because I only thought of your system as a cleaning system with little sonic improvement. I've owned this for years, but I have never had occasion to use it in this manner...it's always been treat a new album or treat an old album. Never have I played an oldish album THEN cleaned it. Boy what a surprise. I have to pay more attention in the future!Russell Marcks
Name: DavidZ HCA LP Cleaner
I can highly recommend George Merrill\'s hydraulic cleaning apparatus to anyone who is interested in extracting the most music from their vinyl collection.
I\'ve been using it for a couple of years and couldn\'t listen to vinyl without it.
It is a simple, effective design (the kind that always look easy in hindsight) that really gets the job done. Thanks George!
— David
Name: Derwin Serrano RCC Mat
Excellent mat and a bargain at this price. High quality, durable mat that has improved the overall sound performance of my turntable notably on rythm and bass. Would recommend this product.
Dear George, Merrill Heirloom Turntable
It was great chatting with you yesterday and I'm pleased to hear you're in good health as well as still in the audio business.
As I mentioned, my Heirloom is still working as well today as the day I received it over 25 years ago. As an aside, a friend who was running a hi-end audio shop (dealing mostly with Lynn) got a bit upset when I told him my turntable appeared to be much more musical in every way than the Lynn brand he was selling and brought over a couple of his favorite LPs to check it out.
He had several excuses for why your table sounded so much better but never commented on how
much better the Heirloom with the Stax arm and Garrott P77 sounded than LP 12 and associated arm and cartridge were lacking.
Today my system consists of the Heirloom and Stax arm and just for a change I replaced the Dynavector 20X with a BINZ15 MC. It needs breaking in but I was told it had a sound similar to the P77 and at least, to my old ears, it's a nice change...very open and dynamic and while I had a wide sound stage until I changed it out, it's even wider yet.
Included a pic of a goofy guy you've been dealing with all these years...now a retired engineer with a cat for company.
Best regards, Bob
George, AR Modifications
Thanks for getting me the polyplatter inner and outer set. It made a big difference, along with subchassis. The bearing is much smoother, the background is darker, and the dynamics have increased dramatically. Everything is more solid in the sound. I am really not sure how good the Ortofon Cadenza Bronze is now or my Balanced Audio Technology components are! Everything stepped up a level. I am sure a Tri-planar arm and your R.E.A.L table would be scary good.
Thanks,
Jim Stenstrom
Hey George, PolyTable Turntable
So, I did a little listening over the weekend...not as much as I wanted too, but there is no need. The few LP's I got to spin were exactly what I've been wanting to hear for so long, just the music on the record! I'm starting to think a lot of the coloration or brightness/darkness I've heard over the years wasn't so much the cartridge as it was the turntable/tonearm combo...
That arm is great and paired with the Orto 2M Blue, the whole system is so synergistically well matched that finally, I can just listen to music and not worry about all the little things that have been an issue in the past. The platter has no run out or platter wobble and that is a HUGE deal for me...
This is the machine I've been seeking for a long time...too bad I didn't find out 15 years earlier!
Pic's attached.
LP in the pics is the Mo-Fi pressing of Linda Ronstadt SIMPLE DREAMS
- Joe D.
Hey George, PolyTable Turntable
So, I de-mounted the Ortofon and mounted the Audio-Technica AT95Sa Cartridge. With the Ortofo, I was suffering from rolled-off High's and a rather, at times, edgy presentation. Sounded almost like there was something resisting or trying to restrain the output.
I just happen to have a custom ARC Protractor here that I had made for a Jelco SA-750D some time back...Interesting geometry that Jeco chose for this arm. There specs with the overhang of 15mm results in an inner null point almost off the playing surface and just inside the Stevenson null point. However the outer null point is very interesting. It's between Stevenson and Berwald. Again, odd.
With the Orto, I figured the loss of HF was in part a Geometric alignment issue (I've experienced this before in the past...long story), so I re-aligned the cart to Jelco's specs. This had a very minor effect in that HF was slightly improved, but the HOT, sometimes edgy or what I would call strained cherictor was still present. This, I 100% atribute to my Integra Phono stage. I believe the Orto is just to HOT and is, I believe (but could be wrong), over driving my modest little phono stage...Time to swap out the 2M Blue for the AT95Sa
The AT95 has been around since Moby Dick was a guppy and I know from experience, it has a more traditional Hi-Fi sound...the Sa version is equipped with a Shibata stylus so VTA and Azimuth are now CRITICAL. I set my VTA and Azimuth and then made my overhang/geometric alignment using the Jelco Arc. Night and day difference, the AT95Sa sounds Amazing on this arm/table combo. The AT95Sa seems to be a better match to my humble Integra phono stage and I will say that the increased resolution and improved inner groove tracing, thanks to the Shibata stylus, are a welcome addition.
With the Orto paired to my phono stage, it was fine with Acoustic and easy listening music, but when it came to harder Jazz, Rock, and other aggressive types of music, it sounded as though it was being restrained or held back. With the AT, everything now flows as it should with out any restriction or edginess.
All-in-all, the PolyTable is still the BEST if not THE very BEST table I've listened to in the last decade. It just sounds good and every time I turn on the power, it does what it's supposed to do...no surprises, no issues...just plays records...
- Joe
GroOove Lube
The Groove Lube is great . More than subtle improvement - especially things like background vocals (I can now pick out the different voices instead of sounding as one) . Also when the levels of the instruments and vocals are increasing to a crescendo the different voices and instruments stay separated instead smashing to together. The before and after — is instructive.
- Preston
Merill-Williams Turntable
George,
This combination of Real 101.2 and Triplanar tone arm is an absolutely exciting listening experience. The sound is virtually neutral yet there a refined detail with a punch that makes listening relaxing, exciting and enjoyable. I really like the simplicity and small footprint of this deck. It exudes engineering prowess. This is my second mass driven solid deck table and it is a much better sound than the "clinical / dry" experience of others I have tried. This setup also avoids the heavy coloration of sound that many decks offer. I am very pleased with this table's looks, ease of setup, and sound. I am proud that this American made combination can stand toe to toe with many other more expensive rigs. Well done!
Regards
Mike Madey
George, Merrill-Williams Turntable
I just want to tell you this is the very best analog playback I've ever heard. The 101.2 outperforms the $16,000 Basis turntable that it's currently sitting next to. And that's with the Shick, I can only imagine it with a Phantom or Triplanar.
Thanks so much for your great work and Happy Holidays!
- Joe Nicolosi
George, HCA LP Cleaner
I received the Gem Dandy record cleaner yesterday. I had some free time this afternoon, so I opened the box, set it up in the kitchen, grabbed a bunch of towels and a box of albums I've been waiting to clean, and went to work.
3 hours later, and I am smiling like a kid at Christmas. I am currently listening to an old album by Seals and Crofts. Not only does it sound fantastic, but I keep turning my head, going "what was that?" I am hearing things I don't remember hearing before. I keep digging out old albums to clean and listen to. I can't clean them fast enough. (actually I could clean them faster, but I can't listen to them any faster!)
Many of the albums I have been cleaning are old - maybe not gramophone old, but many are 30-40 years old - Simon and Garfunkel, Seals and Crofts, The Doobie Brothers. Like many audio nuts I've kept good care of my gear, but keeping vinyl LPs clean is always challenge.
Your product is definitely a god send.
Thank you.
- Eric
Name: Steven Brown Equipment Purchase
My move from Kentucky to Texas has gone well George and I wanted to take a few moments to share my experience with you and some other analog fans. As an original owner of a VPI HW 19 that has seen a
great deal of vinyl...it was time for an upgrade in many respects. Gone is my original tonearm, the
Sumiko FT-3 Tonearm and Dynavector cartridge. Next came a few simple modifications. I installed a set of your 60 Durometer Feet in place of the originals and replaced my original bearing oil with your
proprietary bearing oil. Fortunately, I had a new tonearm arm board and shipped my VPI to
G.M.A.E. The new Ortofon TA-110 Tonearm and Cadenza Blue MC cartridge along with RCC Record Mat are simply synergy! It took some time to get everything settled in my new digs in Texas but what
an amazing transformation! The Plateau 2 shelf turntable stand is very solid & stable and a perfect place for my Sutherland Ph3D. My first vinyl experience was the Sheffield Lab 23, "James Newton Howard & Friends."
Simply superb.
AR Modifications
To any readers who may be unfamiliar or uncertain about Mr. Merrill, I can assure you that he is not only an accomplished engineer (as exemplified by his own turntable designs) but an absolute authority in all things analog and high fidelity. From what may seem to be a small investment in some of his custom
parts to augment your current system or to purchase a completely new analog system, George Merrill should be your first phone call. It is always a pleasure to explore options with him. His advice is spot on.
Thank you
Custom plinth by Larry Spence
GEM Chassis, platter, inner & outer, and motor
SME M2-9 arm
Ortofon cadenza red cartridge.
Assembled by Dave @ Vinyl Nirvana
It's everything I hoped for, and more!
- Roger
Hi George, PolyTable Turntable
Just wanted to let you know that I am absolutely enjoying the Poly Table still! I did determine that the Jelco arm is really better suited to a Moving Coil and after trying several MM carts, I ended up going with a Dynavector DV-10x5. WOW, this table/arm has really come alive. With the MM carts on the SA-250, I found they all suffered from HF roll off...really bad. Some were better then others, but it just didn't sound right. Switching to the MC was a night and day difference.
Again, thanks for this great table. So many people don't realize what they're missing out on. I'm reborn!
- Joe Aschwanden
Customer
George, AR Modifications
I thought I'd pass this on to you in case you ever get a question likethis.
I did buy a Poly Pulley from Dave A. The one thing that a purchaser of that has to realize is that it sits up higher than the original pulley does—at least higher than the one I had did. It could be that the original had worn and the spindle pushed in further. I didn't realize that for a while, and I thought there was something really wrong—long story. Anyway, obviously, the table had to be realigned because of that. Once set up, though the new pulley is a major improvement.
I have to say that between the pulley, the new motor, and a new belt,I'm amazed at how much better this table sounds—and it sounded really good to begin with. I used to think bass was a weakness, but that's not so at all! Ofcourse, it helped to get rid of that infernal Souther. I continue to beimpressed with the Ortofon 110A and the Cadenza Bronze. I can only wonder what your new stuff sounds like, but at 71, I think I can live with what I have.
I guess the only other improvement I might try some time is the power supply. I already have the new mat, center clamp, and the white springs. I have no idea what other upgrades you have. I think mine is an Heirloom I (1985).
Anyway, this has turned out to be one heck of a front end. Thanks for making it.
- Roger
Hey George, PolyTable Turntable
Just thought I'd send you a couple of pics of the PolyTable/Jelco SA-250 in action with the Dynavector DV-10x5. It's playing the Analog Productions 45rpm pressing of Hugh Mesekela's album, HOPE. Sounds incredible!!!
On a side note, what would the advantage of using the Polyweight be for me at this point?
- Joey
Very happy Poly Table owner! PolyTable Turntable
PS I couldn't wait!
So I went in my back garden where there is (almost) a compatible faucet. I soaked myself in the process but the two records I've cleaned and treated are a 1950s LP of Bach Brandenburg Concertos and a 1963 recording of Bill Evans.
Both were extremely dirty and ill-treated but the results are astonishing! I know I can't get rid of all the clicks caused by actual scratches but the sound is pretty revelatory – especially on the (mono) Bach!!
I'm going to have fun with this machine.
Many thanks.
- Tony
Merrill Replica Turntable
Hi George! I hope all is well with you. It's been a crazy year or so, but I'd finally like to submit a review:
Take care, John
"I've had the Merrill Replica turntable for a bit over a year, and it has performed perfectly. Mechanically it is dead quiet, and it is as beautiful sonically as it is aesthetically. The mahogany sets it apart from everything else in the room and it looks and sounds like the true centerpiece of the system. It is fitted with the Jelco SA750D tonearm and an Ortofon Kontrapunkt b cartridge. The sound is absolutely exquisite, and those silent passages on albums are just that, silent. But perhaps the aspect of buying and using this table that has been the most fun has been speaking with and learning from Mr. Merrill. George is a true gentleman and an expert in his field who obviously loves what he does and graciously shares his knowledge and love of the art with others. I can't put into words what a pleasure it has been to work with him."
Hi George AR Modifications
I got the hole drilled on the outer platter today and installed the new inner platter. Man, what a difference, like buying a whole new turntable! I just wanted to thank you for your service and the improvement in sound.
Thanks again.
Cheers
- Jonathan Stutt
Hi George, PolyTable Turntable
PolyTable arrived fine. Sounds wonderful. With Hana, Vincent, PrimaLuna Dialogue Premium HP (KT150 & Mullard CV4003) and Revel F206 Is a marriage made in heaven I think. Really love the vinyl sound. Seems like you feel the music on a deeper level.
Really appreciate it.
Thanks,
- Leo
AR Modafications
Good morning! Well, I got the subplatter, platter, headshell, new cartridge, and new belt installed (I could not remove the pully to change out the motor, so any ideas you could give me on that would be much appreciated) and this is what I wrote last night to a friend:
Wow… Just wow. I completed the modifications to my AR turntable, and it sounds so good. The new sub platter, new platter, new belt, new headshell, and new cartridge. The sound is so much more relaxed, soundstage depth increased a lot, the bass response increased but also tightened up, and a little more detail as well. The added detail isn't like I'm hearing new stuff, but I'm hearing the stuff that's there a little clearer. That old "removal of a veil" that is so overused in our industry, but in in this case it's true. Imaging is very stable. The only adjustment left for me to make is to fine-tune the VTA, as I've got the alignment and overhang nailed. So it could get a little better still. Am also not sure if the cartridge needs some break-in as well. Time will tell.
So there you have it. I had to use the really heavy duty springs I bought from you about 20 years ago (yep, it's been that long - probably early 1990's) since the new platters and my record clamp (made by a friend. It weighs about 16 oz) weigh so much more. With the clamp on the dust cover now does not fit, so I'll need to look for another dust cover that is a bit taller. I also put three layers of heat shrink tubing on the tonearm to help kill vibrations as well. That makes it look like a very fat MMT tonearm! :+)
So thanks again for your products, they are awesome, and next time I'm in Nashville I'll look you up, and dinner and drinks will be on me!
- Al
AR Modification
Hi GeorgeThanks for all your help with the arm board. It really looks great, and very glad I had you do your magic instead of me trying too.
The table really sounds wonderful. How much do I owe you for your work and shipping?
One question regarding maintenance: what type of of bearing oil do use and recommend. And how often or time do you replace the bearing oil?
Thanks again George. You created a masterpiece and a great sounding table.
Merry a Christmas
- Ronald
George, AR Modification
Just a quick note to let you know how thrilled I am with your co-polymer sub chassis for my AR Turntable! I was expecting a quieter sound floor, and it certainly delivered that. However the big surprise was in sonic quality improvement. I found the difference as great as changing from the stock arm to the Jelco 750D — the bass is deeper and more defined, the soundstage is wider and deeper, and the mids and highs are detailed and precise. I'm now truly looking forward to receiving a new Hana SH cartridge!, thanks for all your help.
- Denny
Dear Mr. Merrill, HCA LP Cleaner
For the Feedback section of your website:
Today, July 6, 2017, I just completed washing and applying GroOove Lube to the last of 941 LP's. That is 1,882 album sides washed and dried and 1,882 album sides to which the GroOove Lube was applied.
These albums, many dating from the 1960's, were stored in their original paper sleeves, (some had original plastic sleeves) for more than 35 years. The LP's, belonging to my wife, had not been played for 20 years.
After we moved from Los Angeles to Madison, Wisconsin, conditions and finances allowed us to acquire a new stereo system. I read reviews online and looked at YouTube video reviews of almost all the available record cleaning systems.
The arguments for sonic cleaning machines were compelling but the price tag was not in our budget. I read reviewers who wrote, I am familiar with the sound of cleaned LP's but these took cleaning to another level.
I recognize everything is a matter of degree and that some cleaning systems most certainly can achieve greater cleaning than others. At the same time I was reminded of a Jerry Seinfeld joke when he riffed on a laundry detergent's claim that it will make clothes "whiter than white."
Having read all the reviews on George Merrill's web site:
http://hifigem.com/hydraulic-lp-cleaning-apparatusMKII.html, I decided to commit to the system.
Although the albums were stored vertically it was evident that residue from the paper sleeves and the plastic sleeves had indeed deposited onto the vinyl. The only tweaks I made to the method of cleaning was after spraying the Super Solution onto the LP I did not leave the LP in the vertical position but set the device on its' side; the solution adhered to the vinyl and did not fall off from the underside. I also transferred the solution to a spray bottle with a trigger which made application go faster.
After soaking for one minute the solution was hosed off with high power water spray and then dried with micro clothes. I did not apply the GroOove Lube while a record was spinning. I set the washed and dried LP down on a Mobile Fidelity sleeve, applied the GroOove Lube, then buffed it out with a micro cloth and repeated on the other side.
My wife always tries to get me to use hand lotion because my skin is dry. After applying the GroOove Lube the vinyl soaks it up like dry skin. The label says "The LP Elixir of Life."
Buffing the LP after the GroOove Lube had been applied, I noticed what appeared to be the equivalent of a clear coat on a new car or clear coat on nails. This does not mean to imply in any way that the GroOove Lube is applying a coating, only that the appearance of the LP is so brought back to life that it appears brand new. Elixir of Life may sound like marketing hype but I assure you it is not. It should be called Re-Animator because it brings the LP back to life.
Mr. Merrill responded to all email inquiries immediately such as should cleaning be used on new records and is the Super Solution safe for CD's; yes to both.
I have attached pictures of the process; they include a picture of the set-up, a picture of the LP after being sprayed with solution, after being dried, pre- GroOove Lube and a close up after the GroOove Lube has been buffed out.
As they say, a picture is worth . The price for the entire system is almost a bargain, even with additional ordering of Super Solution and GroOove Lube. I applied both liberally and they cleaned more LP's than Mr. Merrill conservatively estimated they would.
A thoroughly cleaned piece of vinyl that is more than 40 years old on a turntable (ours is the Pro-Ject RPM 10 Carbon with Sumiko HO Blackbird) has more surprise and delight than we could ever have imagined.
Thank you Mr. Merrill for a quality product at an affordable price.
Sincerely,
- Christopher Frank & Jamie
George AR Modifications
Really sounds fine with Benz Ace L cart. Love the arm, your arm board dead quiet. Easy install, video helped. DB systems protractor setup cart. All very good thanks much. Spun some Joe Pass last night, Sweet.
Best,
- Christopher AR Turntable
Hi George, PolyTable Turntable
Received the Gem Dandy Polytable Super12 Turntable in great shape, wonderfully packed.
Instructions and Setup were a breeze. I'm 62 yo and have had my share of Turntable setups/installations like over 12. None over $1500.
I must say initially that the sound I'm hearing is incredible for this price point. I have auditioned many analog rigs twice if not four times/10 the price of this rig.
Glad I picked your creation/design. A big smile is on my face. I'm hearing things on my system that I never imagined would be possible.
Just a few random thoughts and observations.
LP 33 1/3 Examples :
Hank Mobley - Workout - voices and sounds coming out the musicians I've never heard before. Wide soundstage and dynamic range.
Iron Butterfly - Ball - Bass from Lee Dorman's Bass, Ron Bushy's voice placement was just right on and various guitar fuss, drum set made me feel I was right in there.
Mason Williams - Phonograph Record - Everything was more expansive and separation was at a maximum. Classical Gas... well the best sound performance I've ever experienced.
Golden Earing - Moontan A real gem of an album came over like the musicians were live and right there. Punch. Just like the Portland State University live concert of 1985. (without the crowd)
I know it's early on.... but your table is impressing the hell out of me.
Tears of Joy.
Can it get any better?
- Jon
Merrill Heirloom Turntable
George i just wanted to thank you for all of your help and assistance over the last few months updating my system. It is rare to be able to buy a wonderful state of the art system and three decades later have the same person who built it for you still be there to update and continue to help. Today my heirloom is as state of the art as it was when i first bought it from you.
The new power supply and other small adjustments have really made a difference thank you so much and I wish you well. Your contribution to sound is truly not a small step but a huge one.
- Thank you Bob Levy
Merrill Heirloom Turntable
All the final adjustments are done and the Merrill table is one of the highest quality best tables you can buy at any price.
Thank you George for a restoration of our favorite table of all time. Really outstanding quality thanks George.
Thirty years after purchase it still smokes the known universe….father bob and crew
Good Afternoon George HCA LP Cleaner
I am writing you this afternoon to thank you for yet another exceptional product!I ordered my Hydraulic Cleaning Apparatus several months ago and have now gone through many cleaning sessions with great results. These days, ordering LPs from the internet is all too easy. While this is a convenient way to make a purchase, the records acquired online are often in poor condition upon arrival. No matter, with the Hydraulic Cleaning Apparatus I have brought these shining vinyl beauties back to their sonic greatness!
An unexpected bonus is that using the Hydraulic Cleaning Apparatus is a lot of fun, and has become a family affair. As you can see from the attached image, my son enjoys helping out when a new stack of used vinyl comes in and needs a deep cleaning!
Thank you again
- Andrew Ward
TESTIMONIAL AR Modification
You might find it interesting to hear I recently had an opportunity to compare my modified AR to a Clearaudio Master Solution ($10k) turntable with my audio system and the expensive table had NOTHING on mine! It wasn't quieter, it didn't have more top end sparkle or bottom punch, and it didn't give you a larger soundstage. It had a $2k+ Benz Micro Ruby 2 cart, and mine the $750 Hana SL. If anything, I'd say the AR had more LIFE to its sound.
Thanks for all your contributions to those efforts ?
- Denny
PolyTable Turntable
I have owned a PolyTable SUPER12 for several months and thought I'd set down a few of my experiences with it.
The PolyTable SUPER12 arrives well-packaged in one big box. Upon removing the turntable's parts from the box I was impressed by their high quality and superior fit and finish. It was easy and quick to set up due to the excellent instructions.
The Jelco 12-inch tonearm is easy to set up, with adjustments for everything. George Merrill's YouTube setup video was very helpful since the 'arm comes with no setup instructions or templates - I had to get an alignment template online. I'm using Hana SL and Dynavector 10X5 cartridges. The tonearm is an excellent match for these cartridges and seems to be non-fussy about cartridges appropriate to its mass.
The turntable is absolutely silent with no vibrations, both when idling and in operation, a product of the Fluid Damped Drive Motor System. The speed is very stable and on-pitch due to the Digital Motor Drive.
The best description of the turntable's sound is that it has none: It is completely neutral. There are no colorations introduced by the 'table. The bass is strong and well-controlled, without the muddy, indistinct sound of some turntables. The midrange is very satisfying, with voices and instruments surprisingly clear and natural-sounding. And the highs are pure: not beaming, or glaring or grainy.
The turntable has a wide, deep and high soundstage. And its pace and dynamics are as good as I've ever heard from any turntable, no matter the price.
The PolyTable SUPER12 is individually crafted for the buyer and is signed by its designer and builder, George Merrill.
My experience with this turntable has been extremely positive. It has been a joy playing through my record collection, appreciating all the more my favorites, and finding new favorites among those I thought were not so great.
If you are looking for a turntable that is several steps up from a basic model, do yourself a favor and take a look at the PolyTable SUPER12. At $2995 it's a steal and equal to turntables costing thousands more.
— Mike Nichols
John Hillig Musical Concepts Merrill Heirloom Turntable
I got around to installing the DMD and motor. Wow, what an improvement.
Stunning really! Thank you George!
- JH
Hi George. AR Modification
I've had the DMD and Motor in for over 1 week.
It's superb. Increased clarity and resolution. Blacker backgrounds. Quieter. I pretty much expected this. The added bonus was PRAT!
Pace Rhythm and Timing. It's closer to a garrard rim drive in terms of that attribute. So rhythm sections possess a clarity and DRIVE not heard before.
Fantastic, Thankyou very much.
I think I can call my turntable a Merrill now :)
Sensational!
cheers,
Paul Seymour.
Melbourne Australia.
What speedy delivery! Thanks, George. PolyTable Turntable
Just to let you know, I sure didn't expect all that much from any mat but I was pleasantly surprised with your GEM Dandy! I never believed that any mat could ever really open up depth in a recording but I can see how that all works now. Once even the slightest bit of rumble comes close to being totally eliminated, small spatial cues can shine through in a well-recorded disc. It was a wow moment! I'm sure glad I waited for your order to arrive! Thanks, again!
- Gary
Greeting George, PolyTable Turntable
Just a quick note to tell you that after running the table now for many moons I have concluded that it is the best $1, 900 I've spent on an audio component with the exception of my Audio Research Sp11mk 2 preamplifier. As a 20 + year audiophile, these are the two pieces that compliment my all time favorite Vandersteen Audio 5A loudspeakers.
Thank you for bringing it to Market!!
ATB,
- Kurt
Name: James Jackson Equipment Purchase
Hi George, You are the best! I love my Quad pre-amp, my Jolida Glass DAC and the turntable mat and record cleaners. All work superbly! Best wishes on all your innovations! James (Jed) Jackson
Hi George, You are the best! I love my Quad pre-amp, my Jolida Glass DAC and the turntable mat and record cleaners. All work superbly! Best wishes on all your innovations! James (Jed) Jackson
GroOove Lube
Hi George
I have OCD when it comes to making vinyl the quietest in the groove that I can.I have a studio and have recorded many different types of before and after cleaning tests etc.I listen primarily on headphones as this is ultimately the most revealing for me, especially with most headphones having a high frequency bump.Back to topic.I purchased from you the Hydraulic cleaner.Recently I have been testing Ultrasonic cleaners and have also a Keith Monks point suction cleaner (new one without the thread).Anyway, after cleaning I applied the Grooove Lube to clean the stylus but also as a finishing product to the record.I was amazed by how much quieter the record is after the application of Grooove Lube!Why is this?Ticks and pops that were there before application are now gone or have diminished in severity.Do you make a larger bottle as I am currently working my way through over 1000 LP's cleaning and re-sleeving.
Kindest Regards
Paul
I have OCD when it comes to making vinyl the quietest in the groove that I can.I have a studio and have recorded many different types of before and after cleaning tests etc.I listen primarily on headphones as this is ultimately the most revealing for me, especially with most headphones having a high frequency bump.Back to topic.I purchased from you the Hydraulic cleaner.Recently I have been testing Ultrasonic cleaners and have also a Keith Monks point suction cleaner (new one without the thread).Anyway, after cleaning I applied the Grooove Lube to clean the stylus but also as a finishing product to the record.I was amazed by how much quieter the record is after the application of Grooove Lube!Why is this?Ticks and pops that were there before application are now gone or have diminished in severity.Do you make a larger bottle as I am currently working my way through over 1000 LP's cleaning and re-sleeving.
Kindest Regards
Paul
PolyTable Signature
Mark Wadelich Good morning George,
The table continues to break in, but I’m guessing the motor andbearing are done. Mostly, the break-in has to do with recalibrating myexpectations about what’s possible with an all analogue musicreproduction system. The level of detail retrieval, sustain (more onthat later), and the seemingly explosive dynamic presentation this tableand cartridge provides is simply astounding. And based on thetonearm/turntable combo, I’m guessing it would support ANY cartridgeregardless of cost(?). I’m still mulling over the MuTech cart…
My wife was part of an all girls choir at the then all girls School ofNotre Dame in Mankato, MN. The choir director—a nun, ofcourse—trained these girls into a very fine ensemble and ultimatelyproduced a couple of all analogue recordings produced by the DeltaRecords label during the 70’s. The girls were selling thesedoor-to-door and to relatives to pay for the effort as well as to raisemoney for the lil’ monastic community. When we married in the late90’s, I asked a high-end dealer I frequented (Corner Audio inPortland, OR) if I could make a DAT recording of her LP to create a CDwhich I presented to her as a Christmas gift. So, with album and ProAudio DAT in tow, we connected it up to the big QuickSilver preamp (thebig, full faced, and full function one of the time) which was supportinga very fine table and cart that totaled somewhere in the $20K(+/-)range.I made the DAT recording and sent it to a local Pro Audio shop totransfer it to CD. The recording was a hit with my darling wife andthat’s what we listen to every Christmas. Everyone loves it.
Yesterday, the ZOTL40 Reference amp arrived back from Mark Scheider atLinear Tube Audio. (Yeah!) My testing identified that all the NOS tubeswere Ok and Mark confirmed that it was a board level component, which hesaid was, “Very unusual.” After letting things settle in for a bit Istarted listening. All I can say is, WOW! Every album I place on theplatter is a revelation, and that includes my wife’s original albumfrom the 70s. There is absolutely no comparison playing the ripped CDvia the fine Yggdrasil and the PolyTable Signature and HanaML. Mywife’s eye’s (and ears) were transfixed to the“illuminated”—her own words—image coming from the speakers. Shedescribed it as being transported back to the church setting where therecording took place.
And now back to the “sustain” idea in my first paragraph. I’vebeen to the campus at Mankato, MN where my wife attended High School andthe church where the recording was made. The natural reverb in thebuilding is fairly lengthy. In the CD is falls off of a cliff; with thePolySignature it seems to go on, and on, and on, naturally. Remarkable.
I listened to several other records and I just walk away wagging my headat what I’ve been missing.
Thanks again George!
—mark
P.S. The record weight makes a difference. The difference is subtle, butquite perceptible as more focus and solidity. Who knew!?
The table continues to break in, but I’m guessing the motor andbearing are done. Mostly, the break-in has to do with recalibrating myexpectations about what’s possible with an all analogue musicreproduction system. The level of detail retrieval, sustain (more onthat later), and the seemingly explosive dynamic presentation this tableand cartridge provides is simply astounding. And based on thetonearm/turntable combo, I’m guessing it would support ANY cartridgeregardless of cost(?). I’m still mulling over the MuTech cart…
My wife was part of an all girls choir at the then all girls School ofNotre Dame in Mankato, MN. The choir director—a nun, ofcourse—trained these girls into a very fine ensemble and ultimatelyproduced a couple of all analogue recordings produced by the DeltaRecords label during the 70’s. The girls were selling thesedoor-to-door and to relatives to pay for the effort as well as to raisemoney for the lil’ monastic community. When we married in the late90’s, I asked a high-end dealer I frequented (Corner Audio inPortland, OR) if I could make a DAT recording of her LP to create a CDwhich I presented to her as a Christmas gift. So, with album and ProAudio DAT in tow, we connected it up to the big QuickSilver preamp (thebig, full faced, and full function one of the time) which was supportinga very fine table and cart that totaled somewhere in the $20K(+/-)range.I made the DAT recording and sent it to a local Pro Audio shop totransfer it to CD. The recording was a hit with my darling wife andthat’s what we listen to every Christmas. Everyone loves it.
Yesterday, the ZOTL40 Reference amp arrived back from Mark Scheider atLinear Tube Audio. (Yeah!) My testing identified that all the NOS tubeswere Ok and Mark confirmed that it was a board level component, which hesaid was, “Very unusual.” After letting things settle in for a bit Istarted listening. All I can say is, WOW! Every album I place on theplatter is a revelation, and that includes my wife’s original albumfrom the 70s. There is absolutely no comparison playing the ripped CDvia the fine Yggdrasil and the PolyTable Signature and HanaML. Mywife’s eye’s (and ears) were transfixed to the“illuminated”—her own words—image coming from the speakers. Shedescribed it as being transported back to the church setting where therecording took place.
And now back to the “sustain” idea in my first paragraph. I’vebeen to the campus at Mankato, MN where my wife attended High School andthe church where the recording was made. The natural reverb in thebuilding is fairly lengthy. In the CD is falls off of a cliff; with thePolySignature it seems to go on, and on, and on, naturally. Remarkable.
I listened to several other records and I just walk away wagging my headat what I’ve been missing.
Thanks again George!
—mark
P.S. The record weight makes a difference. The difference is subtle, butquite perceptible as more focus and solidity. Who knew!?